Maybe I'm too "old school" - but I just can't stop thinking it's crazy to send an e-mail to your database where your call to action is essentially "remove yourself from my database".
I absolutely agree - keeping a clean database is a good thing.
It's a GREAT thing!
It helps with e-mail deliverability, and gives you better data when you're tracking response rates.
But surely it's better to:
- Rewrite the standard unsubscribe text at the bottom of e-mails to make it more clear and obvious to people who don't spend 18 hours a day online, and;
- Monitor your reply-to address, so that you pick up any bounced e-mail addresses, e-mail unsubscribe requests etc to keep a clean list.
Perhaps even explain in your footer, just above the unsubscribe information, that hitting the Spam button hurts your business - and if people want to stop receiving e-mails, all they need to do is click one link (at any time) and their subscription is cancelled.
I'd hate to be losing potential customers because I caught them on a bad day.
People run hot and cold on products all the time - they might sign up, get busy or distracted by life and become completely disinterested in a product for months...
...Then a year later, out of the blue, they buy.
I like what you're trying to do (make it easier to unsubscribe than it is to click a "Spam" button) but I think you're throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
Brent