The one thing they *did* get right, which nobody else did, in the original ad (see it online somewhere) is that it was intended to drive traffic to their website, to then watch the "revealed" 2nd ad in the sequence... so it was an attempt at DR, though not as well executed as it could've been, by a long margin.
My favorite ad was the fedex one with the big carrier pigeons - memorable and showed contrast plus it was funny and effective at communicating their USP.
Inside the 2008 FedEx Super Bowl Commerical | FedEx Newsroom
The napoleon one in the car was good too.
All ads at:
Budweiser's dog and pony show takes top Ad Meter spot - USATODAY.com
Most of the ads sucked and were madison avenue drivel as usual vs DR, and most even did a poor job at branding/awareness. I watched them all online, to see if there were any nuggets. Didn't find any.
-k