Hi Yancey,
Can't you personalise the letter - or won't the chamber let you have access to their database?
I think you may have overdone the scarcity with a time limit, a numbers limit and something else. People may think they don't stand a chance of getting in, so won't respond on that basis. Also, be very careful what you commit to. If you don't get the number of leads you want from this mailing, you won't be able to use that offer again, having already said that it's one time only offer. If this becomes a profitable thing to do, and something you do regularly, then you'll have to come up with new offers every time.
Why is the free report limited to 10 people?
I wasn't sure why you sort of started explaining direct marketing. I wouldn't bother. The aim of the letter is to generate leads, and I don't know that it matters that you use direct marketing principles (do they need to know that now?) If you've only got one page, and can't fully explain what you're talking about, then my instinct is to leave it out. Otherwise you risk confusing people, and as we know, the confused mind never buys.
I didn't like the "kick butt" headline at all - how does that connect with the pain of your market? Also, with one of the other suggested headlines someone used the term "fellow chamber members" or somesuch - but the letter should read as though it's to an individual.
What sort of businesses is the letter going to?
If you're going to infer that as Chamber members they're now getting a new benefit - should you check with the chamber first that it's OK to word it that way?
I think it's getting there, but I'm not sure it connects really with their pain (which is why I asked you what type of businesses). If it's a cross section, then it's difficult to write for them all and that can lead to blandness. I find asking questions helps in getting people to identify their pain/problem. I also find asking questions an easier way to write copy! (You can see how I used questions on this ad:
http://www.ecademy.com/module.php?mod=list&lid=16850 and on my website
www.attractioneers.com )
Irregardless of what I say, I'm sure you'll do well with it anyway! Best of luck,
Jane
