So let me get this straight...
You have a 5+% conversion rate, and you want to make it better?
Good Luck!
Here's a better idea:
Think about JVing this with as many people you can. Contact any list owners, that could possibly fit this criteria (which potentially could be anyone)... and broker a JV deal and go off and make a ton of money!
Possible JV partners:
Seduction community
Unions
All sports... (track, football, etc.--huge opportunity there)
...and on and on.
I'd have to sit here for a minute to brainstorn all the possible partners, but I don't have the time.
I've got to get back to work. I'm writing an ad for a software product... and the learning curve has been a pain in the butt! I've spent much more time on the research part of this ad, than I normally.
But, you've got a winner... especially if you're getting 5% conversion.